Urban Cinefile
"The two of us stood on the actual murder spot for a few minutes in silence, realising that true life, and death, are so much more important than the movies"  -from the filming diary of Alan Parker, making Mississippi Burning
 The World of Film in Australia - on the Internet Updated Tuesday March 20, 2018 

Printable page PRINTABLE PAGE



The way information is packaged, distributed and received in an era with infinite channels of communication, is explored in a montage of stories around a small group of American soldiers stationed at a checkpoint in Iraq. Redacted utilizes a variety of created source material-video diaries, produced documentary, surveillance footage, online testimonials, news pieces, to comment on the disconnect between the surface of an image and the reality of ideas and the truth, especially in time of war. The experiences of these young men under duress are juxtaposed with those of members of the media and of the local Iraqi people.

Review by Andrew L. Urban:
The film begins with two statements - one is gradually 'censored' out of existence, the other reads: 'redacted visually documents imagined events, before, during and after a 2006 rape and murder in Samarra'. US soldier Angel Salazar (Izzy Diaz) welcomes us as he starts shooting his personal video diary. Others are doing the same, but it's Angel's we see most. Through this diary and through other material, including a news report by a French doco team, De Palma imagines a series of events and puts words into the mouths of the soldiers.

But these and the other devices make the film seem documentary than imagined - as the opening statement suggests. So we're being manipulated, and the irony is that the filmmaker is trying to prove how manipulated we are by the various interests around the Iraq war. The danger of fiction masquerading as fact is as great as distortions of fact. But while De Palma shows a vibrant cinematic sense as he attacks his subject, some of it is on the verge of risible. Like when a group of soldiers storms a home and in the midst of the action, a female journalist suddenly appears and thrusts her microphone into the face of a hapless soldier who blusters stupidly.

That risible scene becomes the starting point for a total breakdown in the morals of the soldiers in our frame. De Palma's intent is to imagine how this scenario [the rape of a girl and the murder of her family, which made headlines] might have come about: how do decent young US lads become such monsters. If not for their predicament. But that doesn't excuse the guilty, the men whose flawed character is the real problem. Men have also behaved as heroes in such circumstances. Sadly, US soldiers are not alone in such failures of decency; history, past and present, is full of them. De Palma's heartfelt scream of pain is sincere, but too angry to be rational.

Confronting and challenging but adding nothing new, the best thing that could be hoped for the film is that it helps change US policy - and helps US policymakers to make more intelligent decisions than the ones which ran the Iraq war.

Published November 20, 2008

Email this article

Favourable: 0
Unfavourable: 0
Mixed: 1

(US, 2007)

CAST: Eric 'Happy' Anderson, Izzy Diaz, Patrick Carroll, Mike Figueroa, Rob Devaney, Ty Jones, Kel O'Neill, Daniel Stewart Sherman, Zahra Zubaidi, Suhail Abdel Hussein, Qazi Freihat

DIRECTOR: Brian De Palma

SCRIPT: Brian De Palma


EDITOR: Bill Pankow


RUNNING TIME: 90 minutes


SPECIAL FEATURES: Interview with Director, Brian De Palma; Refugee Interviews; Behind the Scenes


DVD RELEASE: November 5, 2008

Urban Cinefile 1997 - 2018