Urban Cinefile
 The World of Film in Australia - on the Internet Updated Thursday July 10, 2014 - Edition No 905 

Search SEARCH FOR A REVIEW
Our Review Policy OUR REVIEW POLICY
Printable page PRINTABLE PAGE

Newsletter Options - Registration is FREE Help/Contact

RED VIOLIN, THE

SYNOPSIS:
Cesca (Anita Laurenzi), the Bussottis' housekeeper and reader of the Tarot, reluctantly reads the cards for her pregnant and fearful mistress, Anna (Irene Graziloi). When she dies in childbirth, master violinmaker Nicolo Bussotti (Carlo Cecchi) is heartbroken. He completes his masterpiece violin - intended for his child - in their memory, and gives it a unique, red varnish. The violin passes through many hands and many adventures, from its birthplace in Cremona, Italy, to Vienna, Oxford, Shanghai and Montreal. It is played by gypsies and virtuosos alike, by children and veterans, by lovers and by collectors. What began as a perfect musical instrument, has become an item of enormous dollar value, and for some, an object of desire for its own intrinsic worth. Who could have imagined such adventures - except perhaps Cesca. . .

"Heaven's orchestra must be lead by the violin, an instrument that can elicit the most beautiful, soulful sounds and make us cry. Just as a bow paints musical colours as it caresses the strings, so too the journey of this violin, symbolic of passion, love, joy and yearning. Poetic and romantic in the true sense, The Red Violin is an ambitious tale that takes us on a mesmerising journey of discovery. Shot in five languages in as many countries, François Girard's passionate story is intriguingly structured, weaving in and out of the present, as we follow the course of the violin's destiny from its origins. We dip in and out of different times, beginning in Cremona, where a master violin maker obsessively channels his very essence into this 'marriage of science and beauty'. We are captured by each and everyone whose life it touches; each adds his pathos and dreams therein. Our journey ventures into the lives of rich, poor, free, politically constricted. And all the time, we are guided by the inevitability of the old gypsy's tarot cards, which have predetermined its destiny. Symbolic, moving and beautifully shot, The Red Violin is glorious to look at, and its magnificent music will make your heart soar and weep all at once. I must mention a frustrating structural flaw, as some of the flash forwards are not well enough explained. This somewhat spoils parts of the story, which is rather too long. I question too, the credibility of a scene in which copious sexual activity is suggested – all while playing the violin like a virtuoso. But these reservations aside, The Red Violin is a rich marriage of imaginative storytelling and music that will open your receptacles for an emotional experience."
Louise Keller

"Marvellously evocative with its superb cinematography and production design, The Red Violin is also an epic love story in which the loved one is the violin. This is the instrument that makes the soul cry for joy and the heart ache with pain in equal measure and often in rapid succession. In this case, the curiously red violin can also make the wallet sag, its age and beauty now up for sale to the highest bidder, after three centuries of multiple ownerships, ranging from raging gypsies to raving rascals of musical genius. Playing like a historic world tour, The Red Violin is an ambitious film with a great story to tell, structured in concertina fashion, with several elements inter-laced. There are some excellent performances from a large and varied cast, and the music is always sublime. But the film also has flaws that gnaw at us, such as the jarring omission of a couple of plot points that undermine the story's credibility - and the labouring of the structural device that takes us repeatedly to the auction room scene that forms the contemporary platform for the story. And as Louise mentions, the supposedly erotic Jason Flemyng/Greta Scacchi sequences (in Oxford) turn out to a bit laughable. On the other hand, Jean-Luc Bideau delivers a memorable Georges Poussin with an equally impressive young Christoph Koncz (in Vienna) in one of the best of the cameo-stories within the film. It's not faultless but it is energetic and audio-visually satisfying, if a little long."
Andrew L. Urban

"Expectations aren't met in director Francois Girard's follow-up to his wonderful 32 Short Films About Glenn Gould. This episodic offering, structured along the same lines as The Yellow Rolls Royce (1964) and John Badham's excellent 1974 telemovie The Gun, could be sub-titled 'Two interesting stories about The Red Violin, Two dull ones and one really dumb one'. The framing segments involving Bussoti's wife Anna (Irene Grazioli) being told her fortune by housemaid/clairvoyant Cesca (Anita Laurenzi) register in the same cheesy way as an episode of Tales Of The Unexpected (remember that on late night TV??) but there are compensations. The sequences set in cultural revolution China are fascinating and very well acted by Taiwanese star Sylvia Chang, playing a party member and violin owner at a time when the two were not compatible. Scenes of flag-waving, street marching and the Chairman Mao personality cult in full swing are extremely well staged, making the denoument of this passage genuinely moving. The contemporary scenes leading to the auction are fragmented at first before hitting their stride thanks to reliable Samuel L. Jackson's performance as an expert too close to his work and Canadian stalwart Don McKellar as his tech-head sidekick. Matters are only so-so while the violin's in Austria and France in the hands of child prodigy Kaspar Weiss (Christoph Koncz) and they're utterly ridiculous when Greta Scacchi rattles her charms in front of English composer and opium fancier Pope. Watch the scene where she "plays" him while he's playing and I dare you not to laugh. With 40 minutes cut out of what's a long and talky 130 this might have stood out. The beautiful music is there but the human factor lets it down too often."
Richard Kuipers



Email this article

___________________

CRITICAL COUNT
Favourable: 1
Unfavourable: 0
Mixed: 2

___________________

_________________

The Red Violin, begins in 17th century Cremona, in the fictional workshop of master violin maker Nicolo Bussotti.
ANDREW L. URBAN visited 20th century Cremona to find the lutemakers still build the world's finest violins, in the tradition of the past masters.

_________________

_________________

SOFCOM MOVIE TIMES

RED VIOLIN, THE
(Canada/Italy)

CAST: Carlo Cecchi, Irene Grazioli, Anita Laurenzi, Jean-Luc Bideau, Christoph Koncz, Greta Scacchi, Jason Flemyng, Sylvia Chang, Liu Zi Feng, Monique Mercure, Don McKellar, Colm Feore and Samuel L. Jackson.

DIRECTOR: Francois Girard

PRODUCER: Niv Fichman

SCRIPT: Don McKellar with Francois Girard

CINEMATOGRAPHER: Alain Dostie

EDITOR: Gaetan Huot

MUSIC: John Corigliano

PRODUCTION DESIGN: Francois Seguin

RUNNING TIME: 130 minutes

AUSTRALIAN DISTRIBUTOR: Roadshow

AUSTRALIAN RELEASE: September 9, 1999

LANGUAGES: English / Mandarin / Italian / German / French







© Urban Cinefile 1997 - 2014