Urban Cinefile
"I had a middle class, suburban upbringing - which I loathed. I kept my sanity by watching old Hollywood movies on the tv, where everyone was beautiful and had great emotions, and all the staircases had 400 steps."  -New Zealander Martin Wells, co-writer, co-director of Desperate Remedies
 The World of Film in Australia - on the Internet Updated Tuesday September 18, 2018 

Printable page PRINTABLE PAGE



When soldier’s son and officer, Harry Feversham (Heath Ledger), resigns on the eve of his regiment’s posting to the British Empire’s rebellious Sudan in 1875, his fellow officers, like Jack (Wes Bentley) and even his fiancee Ethne (Kate Hudson) consider him a coward – and each sends him the traditional white feather insult. His father disowns him. Tortured by self-doubt and not sure whether he is a coward or just against this imperial war, Harry sets off for Sudan when he hears of the dangers his regiment faces, not quite sure what he’ll be able to do. Once there, he meets up with a muscle-bound and merciful mercenary, Abou Fatma (Djimon Hounsou), who takes him under his wing. Hiding in Arab clothes, Harry gets behind enemy lines but his efforts to warn his regiment of impending disaster are foiled by his army friends’ arrogance. In the bloody battle that follows, Harry gets to redeem his honour, at a great price. 

Review by Louise Keller:
The film is an epic disaster from start to finish, but the DVD at least has some background featurettes to get your teeth into. There are eight featurettes – most of them short – but the one that canvasses the historical perspective is reasonably solid at 16 minutes in length.

Although Shakhar Kapur would have to shoulder a great deal of the blame, barbs can also be thrust at Michael Schiffer’s unengaging screenplay, Steven Rosenblum’s disjointed editing and a lacklustre performance from our Heath. The film is excessively and tediously overlong – I felt as though I had walked through the desert myself, with no mirage in sight. 

So what went wrong? An ambitious story about love and courage, The Four Feathers tries to be Lawrence of Arabia with a central love triangle, with a story of heroism, brotherly love, loyalty and paternal approval thrown in for good measure. And the four white feathers - the symbol of cowardice - manage to successfully be kept safe with the protagonist throughout all his ordeals and near-death experiences, so he can occasionally look at them (in close up) and take them home with him again. 

It’s a miscalculation on all counts, and a sorry spectacle that never works. The storyline jumps here, there and everywhere and we feel strangely disconnected throughout. Even the spectacular battle sequence in the middle of the desert, which should be impressive by anyone’s standards with camels and horses approaching from all directions, falls somewhat flat when we don’t really know what is happening. 

It must be said, however, that the settings are splendid, with its exotic Moroccan locations and vast desert whose curves and shadows seem to extend forever. And the English locations such as Hyde Claire Castle and Blenheim Palace (where Winston Churchill was born), are regal and full of tradition and ceremony. But Heath Ledger is totally un-charismatic, and instead of following his plight sympathetically, found myself rooting for Wes Bentley’s patriotic Jack Durrance. Bentley gives a terrific performance, making the most of the script to hand, and creating a character with whom we can relate. 

Kate Hudson, restrained by a dull role, shows plenty of style with her understatement, and the non-existent charisma between Ledger and Hudson does nothing for the film’s emotional heart. Even James Horner’s large orchestral score seems to lack innovation – the music is rather formulaic and never leaves us with a heart-felt poignancy. Adding insult to injury, after nearly two and a half hours of misconceived artistry, the ending leaves us incredulous. The Four Feathers is a disappointment of immeasurable proportions.

Published December 25, 2003

Email this article


CAST: Heath Ledger, Kate Hudson, Wes Bentley, Tim Piggott Smith, Djimon Hounsou

DIRECTOR: Shekhar Kapur

SCRIPT: Michael Schiffer (from A.E.W. Mason novel)

RUNNING TIME: 131 minutes

PRESENTATION: Widescreen; 2.35:1; dolby digital 5.1

SPECIAL FEATURES: screen; 2.35:1; dolby digital 5.1 SPECIAL FEATURES: Featurettes – The Friendship of Abou Fatma; Surviving the Prison; A Journey of Self Discovery; The Mystery of the Desert; The Sounds of East and West; The Battle of About Clea; A Journey From Within; A Historial Perspective


DVD RELEASE: December 10, 2003

© Urban Cinefile 1997 - 2018